On Tuesday we explained that Michigan’s default rule lets a new member into an LLC only with a unanimous vote of the members, unless the operating agreement says otherwise. A Michigan Court of Appeals case shows what happens when the operating agreement says both. A father who owned most of a family LLC added his second son as a member with a handwritten note, without the signature of his first son, who was the only other member. After years of litigation, two trips to the Court of Appeals, and an application to the Michigan Supreme Court, the courts upheld it.
The case is Allen & Allen Properties, LLC v Smith (Michigan Court of Appeals No. 365970, decided August 22, 2024).
What happened
In 2004, a father and one of his sons formed a Michigan LLC. The father contributed $710,216 and took a 90% interest. The son contributed $41,560 and took 10%. In 2010, the two of them signed an operating agreement, which included a clause sending disputes over the agreement to arbitration.
In 2014, the father signed a handwritten amendment, by himself, that changed the ownership: 50% for himself, 25% for the son who was already a member (the first son), and 25% for his other son (the second son). The first son did not sign it and said he did not learn of it until after his father died in August 2020. Neither side challenged that the father actually wrote it.
After the father’s death, the second son wrote that he owned part of the company and intended to begin winding it up and liquidating its assets. The first son and the company sued, asking the court to declare that the second son had no interest and that the first son, as the only remaining member, now owned 100%.
What the trial court decided
The trial court first sent the whole dispute, including the membership question, to arbitration. In 2022, the Court of Appeals held that was a mistake and sent the case back for an evidentiary hearing. The second son could use the arbitration clause only if he was a member, so a court, not an arbitrator, had to decide that question first. When the case went back, the trial court held the hearing, found that the second son was a member, and again sent the remaining dispute to arbitration.
What the Court of Appeals held
The first son and the company appealed again. The Court of Appeals upheld (affirmed) the trial court’s ruling in an unpublished opinion issued August 22, 2024. The court denied reconsideration, and in January 2025 the Michigan Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
Did the operating agreement require everyone’s consent?
The fight was over Section 5.1 of the operating agreement. Its first sentence said: “New Members may be admitted to the Company without the prior written consent of all Members.” The rest of the same section pointed the other way: no member could transfer any part of an interest, or let an assignee (someone who receives a member’s interest) become a member, without the prior written consent of all members. A transferee could become a member only after agreeing in writing to be bound by the agreement and meeting other conditions.
The first son said the first sentence was supposed to begin with the word “No,” so that new members could not be admitted without everyone’s consent. He had support: the rest of Section 5.1 pointed that way, and another section said an assignee receives only distributions and does not become a member. Operating agreements the father had used for other companies began Section 5.1 with “No new members may be admitted.” And the second son testified that he never accepted membership in writing or put money into the company.
The other side had support too. Another section of the same agreement said an assignee “shall be admitted as a substitute Member” without mentioning anyone’s consent. In the father’s other agreements, the matching section expressly required unanimous consent. This one did not.
The Court of Appeals would not treat the first sentence of Section 5.1 as a simple typo. Reading the agreement as a whole, it found provisions pointing both ways and held that the agreement was ambiguous. When a contract can reasonably be read in different ways, its meaning becomes a question of fact to be decided on the evidence, and the court may look at evidence outside the document, such as how the parties acted.
What did the owners intend?
The trial court found that the parties meant not to require everyone’s consent to add a member, and the Court of Appeals found no clear error in it, meaning nothing in the record left the court firmly convinced the trial judge had made a mistake. Several things supported it:
- The father held 90% when the agreement was signed. The trial court found that was why the agreement did not require everyone’s consent to add members.
- Starting in 2014, the company’s tax filings included a Schedule K-1 (the tax form that reports each owner’s share of company income) for each of the three, and the second son’s K-1s identified him as an LLC member.
- The first son said he never saw anyone’s K-1 but his own. But he admitted he was listed as the company’s tax matters partner and that he used his own K-1, which showed his share rising from 10% to 25% under the handwritten amendment, to file his personal tax return.
- Another section of the agreement treated any transfer that violated its terms as a withdrawal by the transferring member. The court found it unlikely that the father would have added his son if he believed doing so would trigger his own withdrawal from the company.
Did the LLC Act require a unanimous vote?
The first son also relied on Michigan’s LLC Act, which says an assignee becomes a member only by a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote. The court pointed to the first words of that rule: “Unless otherwise provided in an operating agreement.” An operating agreement that does not require unanimous consent, the court explained, does not necessarily violate the statute (MCL 450.4506(1)).
What the court did not decide
- The court did not decide that tax forms can make someone a member of an LLC. It expressly declined to address that argument. The K-1s mattered here as evidence of what the owners meant when they signed an unclear agreement, not as proof of admission on their own.
- The court did not resolve the brothers’ underlying dispute about the company. That went to arbitration, and the opinion does not say how the arbitration turned out.
- The opinion is unpublished, so it does not bind other courts (MCR 7.215(C)(1)). It turned on the wording of this agreement and the evidence about these owners.
What this means for your operating agreement
Both brothers had a reasonable reading of the document their father and one of them signed. Because the agreement pointed in two directions, the trial court had to resolve the ambiguity from the agreement as a whole and evidence from outside the document, including the later K-1s, and the Court of Appeals reviewed that finding. A few steps make that less likely:
- Read your operating agreement for consistency. The sections on admitting new members, transferring interests, and amending the agreement should all give the same answer to the question “who has to agree?”
- Decide on purpose whether adding a member requires everyone’s consent, a majority, or a manager’s approval, and say it once, clearly. If you hold a small share, that choice may decide whether you can be outvoted on who your co-owners are.
- Make ownership changes formally: a written amendment or consent, signed by everyone whose approval is required, with an updated list of members. A handwritten note signed by one person invites a lawsuit.
- Pay attention to the company’s tax paperwork. In this case the court did not treat the K-1s as making anyone a member, but it allowed them as evidence of what the owners agreed to. If the K-1s do not match your understanding, raise it then.
- Plan for the death of a majority owner. Here, the father, who could have explained what he meant, had died by the time the dispute began.
For the default rules on buying, selling, and admitting new members, see our Tuesday article on selling or buying a share of a Michigan LLC.
Frequently asked questions
Can one member add a new member to a Michigan LLC without the others’ consent?
Only if the operating agreement allows it. Michigan’s default rules require a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote, both for a person acquiring an interest from the company and for an assignee of an existing member’s interest (MCL 450.4501(2)(a), 450.4506(1)). The operating agreement can set a different rule, and in this case the courts found that the agreement did.
What happens if my operating agreement contradicts itself?
If a court finds the agreement ambiguous, its meaning becomes a question of fact. The court can consider evidence outside the document, such as the owners’ conduct, statements, and past practice, to decide what they intended. That may require testimony or other evidence and can lead to expensive, unpredictable litigation.
Does a Schedule K-1 prove that someone is a member of an LLC?
Not necessarily. A K-1 shows how the company reported income. In this case the court declined to decide whether tax documents can make someone a member, but it allowed them to be used as evidence of what the owners intended when the operating agreement was unclear.
Does your operating agreement say what you think it says?
The Law Offices of Maynard F. Newman, P.L.L.C. reviews and drafts operating agreements for Michigan business owners, including the rules for adding members and transferring interests, so those questions are answered in the document rather than in court.
Schedule a ConsultationPlease note: This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the Law Offices of Maynard F. Newman, P.L.L.C. The law may change, and the outcome of any case depends on its specific facts; confirm the current law and consult a qualified attorney before acting. This content may also be considered attorney advertising.