An owner wants out. A longtime employee wants to buy in. An investor offers to buy half of a co-owner’s stake. In each case, the people involved often assume that a share of an LLC works like a share of stock: the buyer pays, signs, and becomes an owner.
Michigan law does not work that way. Under the Michigan Limited Liability Company Act, buying someone’s interest in an LLC and becoming a member of that LLC are two separate steps. A buyer who completes only the first gets the right to receive the distributions that otherwise would have gone to the seller, and very little else: no vote, no say in how the business is run, and none of the other rights a member has. Whether the buyer takes the second step depends on the operating agreement and, if the agreement is silent, on a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote.
The Money Side and the Membership Side
The Act defines an owner’s stake in an LLC, called a membership interest, as the member’s rights in the company, including the right to receive distributions and the right to vote or take part in management (MCL 450.4102). In a sale, it helps to think of those rights in two groups. One is economic: the right to receive distributions from the company. The other is membership: the right to vote, take part in management, and exercise the other rights that the Act and the operating agreement give members.
When a member sells or gives away an interest, the law calls it an assignment. Under MCL 450.4505, an assignment does not, by itself, let the buyer take part in managing the company or become a member. It entitles the buyer to receive, to the extent of what was assigned, only the distributions the seller would have received. A buyer in that position is called an assignee. Operating agreements often use the word transferee for the same thing.
That gap matters more than people expect. An assignee does not gain a vote over discretionary distributions or over decisions to borrow money, sell property, or admit new members, even when the assignee holds a large share of the economics.
Can You Sell Your Share at All?
Under the Act’s default rule, a membership interest can be assigned in whole or in part. That rule applies “except as provided in an operating agreement,” and many agreements change it. Common restrictions include:
- A requirement that the other members, or a manager, consent before any transfer
- A right of first refusal that lets the company or the other members buy the interest on the same terms before an outsider can
- A price formula, or a ban on transfers to competitors or outside the family
- A provision that any transfer made in violation of the agreement is void
A sale that ignores restrictions like these can leave the buyer with less than they paid for, or with nothing. Before signing anything with a buyer or seller, read the operating agreement and every amendment to it.
How a Buyer Becomes a Member
Under MCL 450.4506, unless the operating agreement provides otherwise, an assignee of an interest in an LLC with more than one member becomes a member only upon a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote. In a single-member LLC, the assignee becomes a member according to the terms of the agreement between the member and the assignee.
Many operating agreements replace the unanimous-vote rule with something else, such as approval by members holding a majority of the interests, approval by a manager, or the written consent of particular members. Because the Act lets the operating agreement set these rules, the agreement’s requirements are the ones that count. Follow them exactly. Acting like an owner afterward does not reliably cure a missed step.
Pay particular attention when one of the members is itself a company or a trust. Its consent has to come from whoever has authority to act for it under its own governing documents. If a member LLC is owned by two people and its own operating agreement requires both of them to approve, a signature from one of them may not be enough.
Once admitted, the buyer has the rights and powers of a member to the extent of the interest assigned. The buyer also takes on the seller’s obligations to make promised contributions and to return certain distributions, under sections 302 and 308(3) of the Act. The buyer is not responsible for liabilities that were unknown to the buyer at the time of admission unless they appear on the company’s financial records, which is one more reason to review those records before closing.
Tax Returns Are Not the Same as Admission
Buyers sometimes point to a company tax return or a Schedule K-1 listing them as an owner as proof that they are members. Michigan’s statute treats records and tax filings as a way of becoming a member in one narrow situation: a person admitted when the company is formed, where the operating agreement sets no admission requirements (MCL 450.4501). A buyer who later acquires an existing member’s interest is admitted through the assignee rules in section 506. A K-1 shows how income was reported. It does not, by itself, show that the members admitted the buyer.
What Happens to the Seller
Unless the operating agreement says otherwise, a member who assigns the entire membership interest stops being a member. That has a consequence people miss: if the seller sells everything and the buyer is never admitted, the remaining members may control the company even though the buyer now holds the larger economic stake.
A seller who assigns only part of the interest ordinarily remains a member. The seller’s voting, management, and remaining economic rights depend on the operating agreement and the Act’s default rules. Under those rules, for example, each member of a company formed on or after July 1, 1997 generally has one vote regardless of the size of the member’s interest (MCL 450.4502). Either way, the assignment does not release the seller from liability to the company under sections 302 and 308, including enforceable contribution obligations and liability connected with improper distributions, even if the buyer becomes a member.
Selling an LLC interest also does not, by itself, end a personal guaranty the seller signed for the company’s loan or lease. Unless the lender or landlord agrees to a release, the guaranty usually stays in place after the seller is gone. Our post on personal guaranties explains why.
A Short Checklist Before You Sign
For a buyer:
- Get the current operating agreement, every amendment, and the company’s list of members and their percentages
- Identify exactly who must approve the transfer and your admission as a member, and how (a vote, a signature, a written consent)
- If any member is a company or a trust, confirm who can sign for it under its own documents
- Get the approval in writing, signed by everyone the agreement requires, before you pay
- Sign the operating agreement or a joinder agreeing to be bound by it, and have the list of members updated
- Review the company’s financial records for liabilities and contribution obligations you would take on
- Check the company’s loans, leases, licenses, and major contracts for transfer or change-of-control restrictions
For a seller:
- Check the agreement for consent requirements, rights of first refusal, and notice deadlines
- Ask the lender or landlord to release any personal guaranty you signed
- Talk to your tax advisor, since the tax result of selling an LLC interest depends on how the company is taxed
If the company has a buy-sell agreement, it may already set the price and terms for these sales. If an owner dies rather than sells, similar rules apply to the heirs; see our post on what happens to a Michigan LLC when an owner dies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sell my share of a Michigan LLC without the other members’ approval?
Often yes, unless the operating agreement restricts transfers. But unless the agreement says otherwise, the buyer gets only your share of distributions and does not become a member without a unanimous vote of the members entitled to vote.
Can I sell half of my interest in an LLC?
Yes. Michigan’s default rule permits a whole or partial assignment unless the operating agreement provides otherwise. A partial assignment ordinarily does not end your membership, but the resulting voting and economic rights depend on the operating agreement.
What is an assignee of an LLC interest?
Someone who has received all or part of a member’s interest but has not been admitted as a member. An assignee is entitled to the distributions that go with the assigned interest, but the assignment alone does not confer voting, management, or other member rights.
Can the operating agreement change these rules?
Yes. The Act’s rules on transfers, on admitting new members, and on whether a seller stays a member apply only if the operating agreement does not provide otherwise. That is why the agreement is the first document to read.
Buying into or selling out of a Michigan LLC?
The Law Offices of Maynard F. Newman, P.L.L.C. reviews operating agreements, prepares transfer and admission documents, and helps Michigan business owners and buyers make sure the deal they sign gives them what they are paying for.
Schedule a ConsultationPlease note: This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship between you and the Law Offices of Maynard F. Newman, P.L.L.C. The law may change, and the outcome of any case depends on its specific facts; confirm the current law and consult a qualified attorney before acting. This content may also be considered attorney advertising.